Showing posts with label rent stabilization. Show all posts
Showing posts with label rent stabilization. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 17, 2008


Update: Rent Stabilization

Looks like I'm not the only one concerned about the latest set of rent hikes.

Legal Services and the Legal Aid Society are challenging them in court, with the support of Christine Quinn.

From Legal Services:
Mercedes Casado, 50, is one of the plaintiffs in the law suit. Ms. Casado, a home attendant who is employed by Union Settlement Home Care, has lived in her Inwood apartment since 1992. Her current rent is $739.31. As of January 1, her rent will increase by $85 to $824.31, a more than 11 percent increase. With this increase, Ms. Casado’s rent will eat up 53 percent of her income. She will have trouble paying for her utility bills and it will be more difficult for her to afford the rising costs of food. Her apartment is badly in need of repair, with broken windows, a hole in the bathroom floor and a clogged sink. Her landlord has not made repairs.

Another plaintiff, Paul Hertgen, has lived in the same Staten Island apartment for 17 years. Mr. Hertgen, a union truck driver, was also the primary caregiver to his wife. In January, 2007, she lost her battle with cancer. His rent is currently $685 a month but will increase by 12 percent to $770 in October.

Wednesday, August 20, 2008


Rent Stabilization 2008

Each year I try to take a look at the state of rent stabilization so I can better understand how it's doing. My conclusion is that this is a worse-than-average year for tenants, especially those with rents under $1000/month. The increases [PDF] are higher-than-average—and in some cases they're record-setting for the past twenty years.

As of October 1, 2008, the basic rent increases for apartments where the tenant pays for the heat is 4.5% for a one-year lease and 8.5% for a two-year lease. (Knock off 0.5% for tenants who pay for their own heat.)

However, for long-term tenants (6 years or more) whose rent is less than $1,000, the increase for a heat-included apartment is a flat $45 for a one-year lease or $85 for a two-year lease. That means a $750/month rent would go up 6% on a one-year lease and 11.33% on a two-year lease.

(Note that there are distinction regarding the circumstances of the tenants and the size and quality of the apartment. A shabby $750/month studio would get the same increase as a well-maintained $750/month three-bedroom apartment.)

Let's go for the historical perspective.

According to my records, the basic one-year increase of 4.5% has been met or exceeded only five times since 1988: 2003 (4.5%), 1996 (5%), 1990 (4.5%), 1989 (5.5%), and 1988 (6%). But if you're a longtime tenant with a rent lower than $750, it would be the highest increase for that period.

Also according to my records, to find a higher rate than the basic two-year increase of 8.5%, you'd have to go back to 1988 and 1989 (9% each). If you're a longtime tenant with a rent lower than, say, approximately $940, there's a good chance you've got what would be an increase higher than anything in that period.

The basic one-year increase of 4.5% is 40.625% higher than the average one-year increase from 1998-2007 (3.2%) and 30.435% higher than the average one-year increase from 1988-2007 (3.45%).

The basic two-year increase of 8.5% is 50.442% higher than the average two-year increase from 1998-2007 (5.65%) and 45.299% higher than the average two-year increase from 1988-2007 (5.85%).

To reiterate: This year's increases are on the high end, particularly for longterm tenants paying rents of $750 or less, regardless of their personal circumstances and the size and condition of the apartment. I also think that it continues to be hard for tenants to figure out whether a one-year or two-year lease would be more advantageous. Anyone have a clue about that?

You might think that people who complain about their stabilized rents don't appreciate how lucky they are considering the "market" rents at this time. I think it's reasonable for people who appreciate their stabilized rents to want to hold on to them as long as possible, especially if they are not independently wealthy or raking in high salaries. The faster that stabilized rents go up, the faster those rents will go off the system. People trying to slow down that process are understandably trying to preserve the system. Landlords and others who push for high increases are both pushing the stabilized rents out of the system and increasing the rents in an arguably inflationary manner that would push the "market" rate higher.

Also on the downside for tenants: Landlords can still invest security deposits in individual low-interest bank accounts, take a cut for maintaining the accounts, and leave only a tiny (and taxable!) amount behind for their tenants. This strikes me as advantageous to banks (who benefit from the low interest rates on huge amounts of money) and landlords (who take a cut of the interest from masses of tenants) while being of no advantage for the tenants, who continue to kick in increases to their security deposits. A more equitable plan would involve the money being considered as pooled into a huge high interest account, perhaps at a rate negotiated by the city or state.

In other words, a landlord with 100 $1000/month tenants theoretically opens 100 separate $1000 security deposit accounts at low interest rates commensurate with the low deposits, takes a cut of the interest for maintenance, and then leaves the rest for the tenants, who upon renewal have to kick in an additional amount to keep up with the increase in rent. Instead, the security deposits could be pooled in the equivalent of one $100,000 account, which would merit a premium interest rate. The interest gained could often if not always cover the average one-year increase of around 3.24-3.45%, precluding the need for tenants to kick in any additional amount, and also leave room for others (i.e. the landlord and/or the government) to take a cut (though I'm not sure why that would be necessary). I have no issue with the custom of landlords holding a security deposit; I just think the current system could be reformed to be better for the tenants without putting landlords at a disadvantage.

Your thoughts are welcome!

Wednesday, April 30, 2008

RENTAL DILEMMA

So it's time for stabilized rents to be considered again. Landlords, pointing to rising fuel and utility costs, are asking for a whopping, inflationary 10-15% hike.

I can understand landlord concern over expenses such as fuel, but I can't help but wince at the giant-sized rent increase they're requesting. Having tracked rent hikes over the years, I believe that the landlords have gotten increases above the inflation rate every year since rent stabilization was instituted. If that's so, tenants have never gotten a break. It's always the landlords who have been favored. So it should come as no surprise that New York City remains one of the most expensive rental markets in the country, and, as Representative Anthony Weiner has pointed out, a large and increasing number of New Yorkers apply something in the vicinity of 50% of their incomes in rent. "Nearly 530,000 renters in the city are spending 50 percent or more of their income on housing, a 14.9 percent jump from 1999, according to data released yesterday by Rep. Anthony Weiner," says an article in Metro New York.

So yeah, fuel costs and utility costs are going up. So are food costs and other costs. All New Yorkers—tenants as well as landlords—are going to have to find ways to get by. The thing about landlords is that they've been getting rent increases beyond the inflation rate for years. They've had plenty of time to sock away funds for the proverbial rainy day (they even get to skim interest off the security deposits of their tenants), and they've even had time to re-engineer their properties to make them more fuel-efficient. The landlords, who have often pointed to rising fuel prices in arguing for sizable rent increases, still have time to make their properties more fuel-efficient.

That is why I don't feel especially sorry for the landlords this year. They've had it pretty good for years. They really don't seem to be in that much trouble as a whole. So I don't think they should get any special treatment this time around. They claim that about 10% of rent-stabilized buildings operate in the red, but I don't see why such figures (which could probably use close scrutiny) should be the basis for a blanket policy that affects 100% of the buildings, perhaps ignoring the percentage of tenants who themselves may be "operating in the red." It's about time that tenants —who vastly outnumber the landlords—will get fresh consideration and the type of sympathy that the landlords seem to have been getting for decades from the Rent Guidelines Board.

Representative Weiner's plan for remedying the rent crisis includes restoring cuts to Section 8 housing, reviving senior housing programs, fully funding public housing, increasing federal bonds for private builders, and cracking down on bad landlords. But why not also look into ways to spare tenants giant rent increases and encourage landlords to embark on alternatives such as making their buildings more energy efficient, since rising fuel costs has is such a chronic problem? Perhaps landlords had more of a case for super-inflationary rent hikes when stabilization was first instituted, but if there were ever such a period I get the feeling that it's long gone. As for that 10% "in the red," maybe a program could be developed to determine whether they should qualify for special treatment.